Guangdong Juyao Intelligent Technology Co., Ltd. · Laser Software & Process R&D
23°07′N 113°15′E · GUANGZHOU · PURE STATIC MONOGRAPH
← Back to research
Material & Process2026-09-06· 9 min read

PMMA laser engraving: scan gap and multi-objective parameter optimization

How power, speed, and scan gap jointly affect energy use, throughput, and material removal.

Abstract study of laser energy input, scan paths, and material response
COVERAbstract study of laser energy input, scan paths, and material response
CORE RESEARCH QUESTION

Core question: how do we avoid single-metric traps such as faster-but-shallower or deeper-but-much-slower?

ABSTRACT

Khan and colleagues examine power, speed, scan gap, and defocus in nine CO₂-laser PMMA engraving runs, using Grey–Taguchi analysis to combine energy, emissions, throughput, and removal rate. This note focuses on how scan gap changes path count and on the limits of multi-objective scoring for material parameter management.

01 / Start with the experimental boundary, not the parameter values

The study used a BODOR BCL 1006 continuous-wave CO₂ laser at 10.6 μm with 80 W maximum power, processing 95 × 90 × 2 mm PMMA specimens. The tested levels were 20/32/44 W power, 300/350/400 mm/s scanning speed, 0.035/0.050/0.065 mm scan gap, and -2.65/0/+2.65 mm defocus.

Nine combinations were engraved in a single pass, with each experiment repeated three times. The authors measured electrical energy, per-part CO₂ emissions, hourly production rate, and material-removal rate, using mean values in the analysis. Machine, wavelength, material, geometry, and objective functions all constrain how the result may be used.

02 / What Grey-Taguchi does: place competing objectives on one evaluation scale

Energy and emissions are smaller-is-better objectives, while production rate and material removal are larger-is-better. The paper normalises the responses to a 0-1 scale, computes Grey Relational Coefficients (GRC), and averages the four responses into a Grey Relational Grade (GRG). A higher GRG means that a run is closer to the ideal under the authors' equal-weight objective design.

The method is interpretable and economical in experiment count. Its limitation is equally important: the weights come from the study design. If a product prioritises surface finish, dimensional accuracy, or safety margins, the objective functions and weights must be redesigned.

MATHEMATICAL MODELEQ. 03
GRG⁡i=1n∑k=1nξi(k)\operatorname{GRG}_{i} = \frac{1}{n} \sum_{k=1}^{n} \xi_i(k)
The paper aggregates the Grey Relational Coefficients ξ of multiple normalised responses into one score.

03 / Result: scan gap controls how much path is travelled; power and speed control material removal

Within the tested range, scan gap had the largest effect on the combined GRG and was the most significant factor for energy, CO₂ emissions, and production rate. A wider gap reduced the number of scan lines, lowering energy and emissions while increasing hourly output.

Material-removal rate was influenced more strongly by laser power and scanning speed. The study's combined optimum was 44 W, 300 mm/s, a 0.065 mm scan gap, and zero defocus. This is a result for the tested machine-process-material combination and the paper's objective weights, not a transferable device preset.

GEOMETRY / Scan gap and path length L ≈ A / Δy

For a fixed filled area: path length ≈ area ÷ scan gap

JUYAO geometric illustration, not measured paper data. The approximation neglects edges, turns, and acceleration. A wider gap does not guarantee better quality, depth, or overall benefit.

04 / Direct implications for a material library and process software

A material preset should not store only power and speed. It should also record source type and wavelength, scan gap, focus offset, geometry type, number of passes, optimisation objective, machine capability limits, and experimental provenance. Otherwise, a preset named simply “PMMA” hides materially different physical conditions.

The interface should not present every parameter as an independent slider. Scan gap changes path length, which changes estimated time and energy; power and speed jointly influence energy per unit length. A better interaction model exposes these relationships and labels literature-derived values as research references until they are validated on the target machine.

  • Paper parameters: stored only as a sourced experimental record.
  • Device preset: bound to a specific source, material batch, and validation record.
  • Recommended value: produced only after replication and safety review on the target machine.

PRIMARY SOURCE DOSSIER

Paper Title
Optimization of Laser Engraving of Acrylic Plastics from the Perspective of Energy Consumption, CO2 Emission and Removal Rate
Authors
Mohammad Muhshin Aziz Khan, Shanta Saha, Luca Romoli, Mehedi Hasan Kibria
Journal
Journal of Manufacturing and Materials Processing, 2021, 5(3), 78
Published
15 July 2021
DOI
10.3390/jmmp5030078
Licence
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
Original URL
Open original paper ↗